Do You Need a Police Permit to Hold a Protest in Nigeria? By Rabiu Muhammad Gama

For a start, protest is something that you do to show publicly that you think something is wrong and unfair. Protest is an expression of disapproval, and it can be done in different forms and on any day; it can be verbal or physical, it can also be done on the social media. In a democratic society like Nigeria, protest is an effective and legitimate tool, usually the only tool, that citizens can use to publicly express their displeasure with regard to some government measures or policies. When the government fails to discharge her duties which she owes to the citizens by virtue of their unwritten social contract, the citizens can hit the streets to register their grievances against the government. The nagging question, which this article sets out to answer, is that must people get a permit from the Governor or the Commissioner of Police before they can convene a protest?

The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended), is the basic law of the land. It is the law on top of which there is no any other law. It is over and above any law, body or authority. It has been aptly submitted that the Constitution of any country, and don't forget Nigeria is still a country, is the embodiment of what the people desire to be their guiding light in governance - their supreme law - the “grundnorm” of all their laws. By virtue of Section 1(3) of the 1999 Constitution, any law, and that 'any' does mean ANY, that is inconsistent or in conflict with a provision of the Constitution, that law is invalid and completely useless due to its inconsistency with the Constitution. Please, permit me to draw an analogy, whenever there is a boxing match in a ring (read: court of law) between the Constitution and any other law, the referees (judges) always rule, and will surely continue to rule, in favor of the Constitution. No law, no matter how strong and powerful its muscles are, can knock out the Constitution. The Constitution always prevails.

The Constitution provides for Fundamental Human Rights, precisely from Section 33 to Section 44, and these Sections can be found in Chapter Four of the Constitution. These Fundamental Human Rights are simply those Rights that every human is entitled to simply because he is human. These Rights cannot be taken away or restricted except in full compliance with the provision of Section 45 of the Constitution and some other relevant provisions therein. Section 39 and Section 40 of the 1999 Constitution provide for the Right to Freedom of Expression and the Right to Freedom of Association and Peaceful Assembly respectively: a merger of these two Sections gives us the Right to Protest. In the light of the forgoing, it is safe to submit that Right to Protest is a Fundamental Human Right which is clearly guaranteed and enshrined by the 1999 Constitution, hence it cannot be restricted by anybody, including the DSS or the Police, or rather particularly the DSS or the Police. It is only the Constitution that can restrict that Right.

Before 2005, there was one undemocratic federal law (Act) which was dripping with dictatorship and some leftovers of colonialism mentality, the Public Order Act. The Law (Act) was originally promulgated as the Public Order Decree 5 Of 1979 and it later become an Act of the National Assembly by virtue of Section 274 of the 1979 Constitution. Sections 1 (2) (3) (4) (5) (6), 2, 3 and 4 of the Act required intending protesters to get a permit from the Governor (he can delegate the powers to the Commissioner of Police) of the state where the protest is to be held before they can protest. When the Governor, or the Commissioner of Police as the case maybe, is of the opinion that the protest is likely to disrupt public order he can refuse to issue the permit.

However,  in the celebrated case of IGP v. ANPP (2008) 12 NWLR 65 when Malam General Muhammadu Buhari (as he then was) and his then political party, the ANPP, lost presidential election in 2003 to Olusegun Obasanjo, requested the then Inspector General of Police (IGP) by a letter dated 21^st May, 2004, to issue police permits to their members to hold unity rally throughout the country to protest the alleged rigging of the 2003 election, the request was refused. They went ahead to organize the rally without the permits. There was a violent disruption of the rally organized in Kano on the 22^nd of September, 2003, on the ground that no police permit was obtained as required by the Public Order Act. The Federal High Court invalidated the provisions of the Act that required a Police permit before a protest is staged on the ground of their being inconsistent with the provisions of the Constitution, particularly Section 39 and 40, and Article 11 of the African Charter on Human and People’s Rights ( Reification and Enforcement) Act, Cap. 10, Laws of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1990.

On appeal, the Court of Appeal also affirmed the decision of the Federal High Court. Right from the Federal High Court, the learned trial judge relied on the decision of the Supreme Court of Ghana in the case of New Patriotic Party v. Inspector general of Police (1992 – 93) GBR 585 – (2000) 2 HRLRA 1 where it was aptly submitted that:

“Police permit has outlived its usefulness, statutes requiring such permits for peaceful demonstrations, processions and rallies are things of the past. Police permits is the brain child  of colonial era and ought not to remain in our statute books.”

That was how the Court sent those unconstitutional provisions of the Public Order Act to their eternal grave. By the way, it may interest you to know that by virtue of Section 83 (4) of the Police Establishment Act, 2020, where a person or an organization CHOOSES to notify the police of his or its intention to hold a public meeting, rally or a procession on a public highway, the police officer responsible for the area where the rally will take place shall mobilize personnel to provide security for the rally! The police or the DSS have no powers whatsoever to stop or restrict the Fundamental Right of Nigerians to freedom of expression and assembly once those rights are exercised within the ambit of the law.

As the law stands today, no police permit is required before staging a protest in Nigeria. Right to Protest is a Fundamental Human Right given by the Constitution which cannot be taken away or restricted except in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution.

Rabiu Muhammad Gama is a Law student from Bayero University, Kano (BUK). He can be reached on 09061912994 or via rabiuminuwa327@gmail.com