NATURE OF A UNIVERSITY’S DUTY OF CARE TO ITS STUDENTS IN THE ADMINISTRATION OF THEIR ACADEMIC AFFAIRS, AND THE LIABILITY BORNE WHERE SUCH DUTY IS BREACHED THROUGH NEGLIGENCE
A university’s autonomy protects academic judgment and not administrative negligence. Hence, a university owes its students a legally enforceable duty of care in tort. The scope of the university’s duty of care include academic, administrative, and pastoral/procedural duty of care, and a breach of this duty in the administration of academic affairs attracts liability in damages.
It is a widely accepted assumption that academic matters fall exclusively within the province of university authorities and should not be subjected to judicial interference. For decades, Nigerian universities invoked academic autonomy as a shield against judicial scrutiny. However, does a university’s academic autonomy permit it to escape liability where negligence is established in the administration of academic affairs?
The very recent Supreme Court case of Victor v. F.U.T.A. (2026) 8 NWLR (Pt. 2044) 33 is an important landmark authority on the extent of university autonomy and the legal responsibility owed to students in the administration of academic affairs, particularly in the handling of examination results. It challenges the assumption that university academic affairs are purely internal matters beyond judicial scrutiny, demonstrating that they may be examined by the courts where negligence or another actionable legal wrong is established.
A detailed and adequate narration of the interesting fact leading to the commencement of this case at the trial court as well as the subsequent appeals to both the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court are as follows:
The Appellant, Mr. Adebayo Afolabi Victor, was a student of Mechanical Engineering at the Federal University of Technology, Akure (FUTA). In 2007, he graduated and was awarded a Second Class Lower Division degree. However, he was of the belief that errors in the marking, recording and computation of his scores had denied him a Second Class Upper Division.
Between 2007 and 2011, he persistently petitioned the University for investigation and remarking. However, the University refused to investigate. In 2011, he commenced an action, in person, at the trial court against the University & Anor., seeking the re-mark of some of the scores/marks for courses he offered during his degree programme in Mechanical Engineering at the University by independent assessors and thereafter have his transcripts and certificate released to him.
According to the appellant, the respondents awarded less Cumulative Grade Points Average (C.G.P.A.) to him, which he said were not his true scores and that the respondents erroneously awarded him Second Class Lower Division, instead of Upper Division.
In its judgment, the trial court granted the claims of the appellant in part. It directed the respondents to re-mark the appellant’s scripts by external examiners in the courses affected and issue to him a final result and transcripts reflecting the results. It then awarded the sum of ₦500,000.00 (Five Hundred Thousand Naira) as general damages in favour of the appellant.
Dissatisfied with the judgment of the trial court, the respondents appealed against same to the Court of Appeal. The appellant cross-appealed on the quantum of damages awarded as being insufficient. In its judgment, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and allowed the appellant’s cross-appeal in part. It awarded the appellant a sum of ₦200,000.00 (Two Hundred Thousand Naira Only) for success in the cross-appeal and ₦50,000.00 (Fifty Thousand Naira Only) as costs of litigation.
Still dissatisfied, the respondents appealed to the Supreme Court in appeal, while the appellant cross-appealed. Upon mediation by the Supreme Court, the respondents withdrew the appeal and same was dismissed.
Pursuant to the directions of the Supreme Court, the respondents filed a notice of compliance detailing the academic transcripts of the appellant showing a re-mark of his scripts by external examiners and a Degree Award of Bachelor of Engineering (B.Eng.) of Second Class (Hons.), Upper Division, and evidence of payment of the sum of ₦500,000.00 (Five Hundred Thousand Naira Only) and ₦250,000.00 (Two Hundred and Fifty Thousand Naira Only) for damages and costs for the unsuccessful appeal.
Upon the notice of compliance, the Supreme Court ordered the appellant to go to the 1st respondent’s University to collect his degree. The Supreme Court was then left with the appellant’s cross-appeal, which was, to a good extent, related to the question of liability for the years of neglect.
In the cross-appeal, the appellant prayed the Supreme Court to, inter alia, allow his appeal, grant an order setting aside the sum of N500,000 general damages for being extremely low, considering the hardships and losses he had experienced over the years in pursuit of his right, and for an award of adequate general damages in line with the principle of restitutio in integrum. He equally prayed for an order setting aside the award of ₦50,000.00 cost of suit for 7 years as being extremely low.
The trial court had awarded only ₦500,000.00 (Five Hundred Thousand Naira Only) in general damages. The Supreme Court held that the award was grossly inadequate and increased it to ₦18,000,000.00 (Eighteen Million Naira Only) in general damages plus ₦2,000,000.00 (Two Million Naira Only) as costs of litigation, totalling ₦20,000,000.00 (Twenty Million Naira Only).
Basically, the position of the law is that, although universities retain autonomy over academic judgments and the award of degrees, such autonomy is not absolute. Significantly, in determining this issue, the Supreme Court recognised that universities owe their students a duty of care in tort, the scope of which include academic, administrative, and pastoral/procedural duty of care. Furthermore, the University is expected to exercise reasonable care in the administration of the academic affairs of its students. To the effect of the foregoing, the Learned Justices of the Apex Court held thus:
“Universities owe their students a duty of care in tort. The duty of care of a university authority to its students over their academic studies refers to the legal and ethical responsibility the university owes to ensure that students are treated fairly, supported appropriately, and not subjected to foreseeable harm including academic, psychological, or procedural harm during their studies. University autonomy does not connote impunity and lack of accountability. A University owes its students a very serious duty of care while they are there enrolled to study. In the instant case, the appellant suffered untold hardship for a breach of the academic duty of care owed to him by the respondents.”
Apparently, this duty encompasses the objective assessment of students, proper handling of academic records, fair procedures, and reasonable consideration of students’ complaints. Consequently, where negligence, arbitrariness, incompetence, or procedural unfairness is established, the courts may intervene without usurping the university’s authority to determine academic standards.
This position of law is consistent with the cases of Mautech v. Yarai (2020) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1748) 395, Unilorin v. Dunmade (2013) LPELR-21383 (CA), Unilorin v. Akinola (2014) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1422) 435, and UniPort v. Nwuzor (2024) 16 NWLR (Pt. 1965) 551. These authorities are quite relevant to the legal obligations of university authorities and the limits of institutional discretion. They reinforce the principle that academic autonomy does not excuse conduct that falls below the standards of fairness, diligence, and proper administration required by law.
Furthermore, where a university’s breach of its duty of care causes a student injury or loss, the institution may be held liable in damages, provided the necessary legal requirements are established. This position is a fundamental and well-established one as adequately reinforced by the Supreme Court that:
“Compensatory damages are paid to compensate the claimant for the loss, injury, or harm suffered by reason of the defendant’s breach of duty…”
Consequently, the Apex Court increased the general damages awarded to Victor to ₦18,000,000.00 (Eighteen Million Naira Only) and awarded ₦2,000,000.00 (Two Million Naira Only) as costs of litigation, bringing the total monetary award to ₦20,000,000.00 (Twenty Million Naira Only). The order for the remarking of his examination scripts had been made by the lower court, and the subsequent review resulted in an upgrade of his degree classification. The principles governing the award of damages are also reflected in Agbanelo v. Union Bank Plc (2000) LPELR-234 (SC). While general damages may be awarded for loss naturally resulting from a proven wrong, special damages, including specific financial losses, must be strictly proved, as done in this instant case.
Based on all the foregoing, to sum up everything that has been stated so far, the case of Victor v. F.U.T.A. (Supra) underscores that a university’s duty to its students extends beyond teaching, examination, and the award of degrees to the fair and responsible administration of academic affairs. Although courts will not ordinarily substitute their judgment for that of academic authorities, they will not allow academic autonomy to shield negligence or other actionable legal wrongs from judicial scrutiny. The decision, therefore, reinforces the principle that universities must exercise their powers responsibly, protect the legitimate interests of their students, and remain accountable where a breach of duty is established.
About the Authors:
Hisbullah Sarkibaba and Amina Muttaka Zakir.
Hisbullah Sarkibaba, SABUK, ACIBF, TPD, is the Director of Research and Litigation, Solace Chambers. While Amina Muttaka Zakir a member of the Research and Litigation Directorate, Solace Chambers, Bayero University, Kano. They can both be reached via 08163807626 and 07037049762, respectively.
Comments
Post a Comment